Lead platforms
Apps like Thumbtack Pro (2026): 10 lead sources compared on their own terms
Ten alternatives to Thumbtack for contractors charge in four ways: per lead (Angi, Networx, Bark, Porch, HomeGuide), per call (eLocal, Service Direct), per valid lead or click (Google Local Services Ads, Yelp) or by subscription (Houzz Pro, $199/mo listed). Each row below quotes the platform's own pages, checked 17 November 2026.
ByEdu López Parada· Founder, Made For BuildersReviewed
Thumbtack Pro alternatives compared: pricing, sharing, contract, refunds
The table sets Thumbtack next to ten other lead sources on four points each platform publishes: how you pay, how many pros can get the same customer, what you commit to and what you can get back. Where a platform does not say, the cell says so. The order is alphabetical after Thumbtack, not a ranking.
| Platform | How you pay | Shared or exclusive | Contract or commitment | Refunds or credits |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Thumbtack (for reference) | Per lead, at a price you set: "the exact amount you’ll pay" (Thumbtack) | Five pros in the first four hours | Weekly budget; "The only thing you pay for is leads" (Thumbtack) | Automatic if the customer replies to no pro in 72 hours; not for jobs you don't win |
| Angi (HomeAdvisor) | Lead fee that changes "based on task, homeowner location, and demand" (Angi) | No more than five pros | Monthly budget, or an annual subscription where the budget "is set annually per your contract"; cancel by calling Customer Care (Angi) | Credits for listed cases, lead under 45 days old; none on annual subscriptions (Angi) |
| Bark | Credits per lead: "Current credit price: $2.35 per credit" (Bark) | Up to 5 professionals per customer (Bark) | Prepaid credits; "unused credits cannot be refunded" | Returns "Within 14 days of the lead purchase" (Bark); not if the customer hired someone else |
| eLocal | Per live call, at pricing you decide (eLocal) | Exclusive calls | "No contracts, no subscriptions, no commitments" | Credit request "within 4-days" of the call |
| Google Local Services Ads | Per valid lead; price varies by location, job type, lead type and bidding mode (Google) | The customer contacts your business directly (Google) | Not covered in the pages checked | Google assesses lead quality "over a 30-day period"; a missed call over 20 seconds is charged |
| HomeGuide | Per lead: "You only pay for the leads you want" (HomeGuide) | "We limit the competition"; number not published | No membership or subscription; pause or stop any time | Account credit for invalid leads, requested "within seven days" (terms) |
| Houzz Pro | Subscription "instead of pay-per-lead" (Houzz); Pro plan listed at $199/mo (Houzz) | Not published | Annual subscription after a free 30-day trial | Not covered in the pages checked |
| Networx | Prepaid leads, "$14 to $100 each" (Networx) | A maximum of four professionals (Networx) | Balance "automatically renews"; "not locked into a long term contract" | Credit back for listed cases (wrong numbers, services you don't provide) |
| Porch | Buy leads one by one or set a monthly budget (Porch) | Not published | Monthly budget if you choose one | Automatic credits if you meet outreach requirements and don't connect |
| Service Direct | Per call; prices "vary based on your business type and location" (Service Direct) | Exclusive calls | "There is no term contract" | Dispute calls received less than 7 days ago; unanswered calls are billable (Service Direct) |
| Yelp | Request a Quote is free to set up; Yelp Ads run on a monthly budget, cost per click varies (Yelp) | Quote requests go to "multiple businesses" (Yelp) | "There are no term contracts" | Not covered in the pages checked |
| Partner Program | Commission on closed jobs only: 20% of labor on service and repair, 15% of the net on installations | One partner per trade per area | Leave with 30 days' notice, no penalty | Nothing to refund: calls that don't become jobs cost $0 |
How these apps charge, and what that does to your cost per job
Per-lead apps charge whether or not you win the job. Per-call sellers charge for the call, including some you miss. Subscriptions charge the same whatever arrives. Commission models charge only when a job closes. Which costs you less per job depends on your close rate, not on the headline price.
Per lead
Thumbtack, Angi, Networx, Bark, Porch, HomeGuide. You pay when the customer is delivered or replies, then compete with up to four or five other pros on most of them. Angi, for example, counts a homeowner who hired another pro as already "accounted for in our lead pricing".
Per call
eLocal and Service Direct sell exclusive live calls. The call is yours, but the billing rules are strict: Service Direct says "Unanswered calls are always Billable." Details on missed-call billing: exclusive contractor leads.
Per valid lead or click
Google Local Services Ads charges per valid lead in your own ad. On Yelp ads "You pay a different price per click depending on the supply and demand of that moment" (Yelp).
Subscription
Houzz Pro bundles leads with business software for a monthly price on an annual plan. Your cost per job is the subscription divided by the jobs it brings, including months with none.
| Model | Example spend | Jobs closed (example) | Cost per closed job |
|---|---|---|---|
| Per lead: 10 leads at $40 | $400 | 2 (1 in 5) | $200 |
| Per call: 10 calls at $90 | $900 | 3 (1 in 3) | $300 |
| Subscription: $199 a month | $199 | 1 | $199 |
| Commission: 20% of $400 labor | $0 up front | 1 | $80, only once it closes |

Work out your cost per closed job before you switch
Take each source's spend for the last three months and divide it by the jobs it actually produced. That one number lets you compare Thumbtack with any alternative, whatever the pricing model. None of these platforms publishes average close rates, so the inputs have to be yours.
A pro on Thumbtack's own forum put it the same way: "I would look at cost per booked job, which services convert best, and which customers become repeat clients" (Thumbtack Community). Another, on the Jobber community forum: "I think when you are starting out you have to try all the major lead sources then see what works" (Jobber Community).
Then check what each job leaves after labor and materials with the job profit margin calculator. Platform-by-platform detail: Thumbtack for pros, Angi leads cost, Networx cost for contractors.
Any lead source: cost per closed job
Run it once per source you use or are considering. Example numbers to start; change them to yours.
Run your numbers
Paying per lead vs paying per job
Paying per lead versus paying a commission only when a job closes. Put in what you pay today and see both models side by side.
Example numbers. Change them to yours.
Labor plus any markup you add to parts. Parts at cost carry no commission.
Buying leads today
$200
per closed job
$1,000 a month for 5 closed jobs
Partner Program
$70
commission per closed job (20 % of labor)
$350 a month if the same 5 jobs came from brand calls
The difference
- Difference per job
- $130
- Difference a month
- $650
On these numbers, the commission would be $130 less per closed job than buying leads: $650 a month.
Hypothetical example using your numbers, for illustration only. Not a prediction or guarantee of calls, jobs or earnings: we don't guarantee any number of calls. Your results depend on your area, demand, prices and work.
Before you sign up: six questions for any Thumbtack alternative
Switching apps changes the rules more than the leads. Before you add a card, find six answers in the platform's own help center or contract: the price basis, how many pros share a customer, minimum term, renewal, refund window and whose phone number the customer keeps.
- Price basis. Do you set the price (Thumbtack, eLocal), or does the platform change it with demand (Angi, Service Direct, Google)?
- Sharing. Is the number of pros per customer written down? Angi, Thumbtack, Networx and Bark publish one; HomeGuide, Porch, Houzz and Yelp did not in the pages we checked.
- Commitment. Annual subscription (Houzz Pro, Angi's annual plan) or a budget you can stop?
- Renewal. Does a prepaid balance renew on its own? Networx says that once you run out of credits "your account automatically renews".
- Refund window. 72 hours (Thumbtack's automatic refund), 4 days (eLocal), 7 days (Service Direct, HomeGuide), 14 days (Bark), 45 days (Angi). Lost jobs are not refunded on any of them.
- The customer's number. On a marketplace the customer found you through the platform. Calls to your own profile, website and number stay with you.
Alternatives that don't charge per lead
Two routes avoid paying per contact: your own channels, where the customer calls your number (Google Business Profile, reviews, referrals, your own ads), and a partner brand built for your trade and area that is paid by commission on closed jobs.
- Your own channels. No fee per lead; they take time and, for ads, a budget. Size it with the Google Ads ROI calculator and the marketing budget calculator.
- A partner brand. In the Partner Program we build and run a local brand for your trade and ZIP codes, and the calls come to you. One partner per trade per area. No setup fee, no monthly fee and no pay-per-lead: 20% of the labor on service and repair jobs and 15% of the net on installations and replacements, only on jobs you close. How commission works.
Made For Builders is not a contractor and does not perform, supervise or guarantee any work. We have no US results yet and do not promise a number of calls. Launch areas: Markets.
Partners keep the calls from their own area. Commission only on closed jobs: see the rates.
Apps like Thumbtack Pro: frequently asked questions
What apps are like Thumbtack for pros?
Angi (HomeAdvisor), Networx, Bark, Porch and HomeGuide also sell leads one by one. eLocal and Service Direct sell calls. Google Local Services Ads and Yelp charge per lead or per click in your own ad. Houzz Pro is a subscription. Their terms, side by side, are in the table above.
What is an alternative to Angi Pro?
Any of the sources in the table. Angi matches each request with no more than five pros and changes the lead fee with task, location and demand; for Angi's own terms see Angi leads cost.
What are the alternatives to Networx?
Networx sells prepaid leads at $14 to $100 each, shared with up to four professionals. Per-lead alternatives are Thumbtack, Angi, Bark, Porch and HomeGuide; per-call alternatives are eLocal and Service Direct. More: Networx cost for contractors.
Which app for contractor leads has no contract?
eLocal says "No contracts, no subscriptions, no commitments", Service Direct says there is no term contract, Yelp Ads has no term contracts and HomeGuide has no membership or subscription fee. Houzz Pro and Angi's annual plan are annual commitments.
Do these apps refund leads that don't turn into jobs?
No. Each refunds or credits only listed cases, such as wrong numbers or services you don't offer, within a set window. Thumbtack also refunds automatically when a customer replies to no pro within 72 hours.
Is there a Thumbtack alternative where I only pay for closed jobs?
Not among the lead apps in the table. The Partner Program charges commission only on closed jobs from calls to a local brand we build for your trade and area, one partner per trade per area.
Sources and method
Every quote and figure on this page was read on the platform's own page on 17 November 2026 and saved with a capture. Platforms whose pages we could not read are left out rather than described from third-party blogs. Example numbers are round and labeled as examples. We do not rank platforms. Reviewed every six months.
Sources
- Thumbtack Help: Why Thumbtack (opens in a new tab)Accessed
- Thumbtack Help: Set lead prices (opens in a new tab)Accessed
- Thumbtack Help: Quality Commitment (opens in a new tab)Accessed
- Thumbtack Help: Refund policy (opens in a new tab)Accessed
- Thumbtack Community: How leads are priced (opens in a new tab)Accessed
- Angi Help Center: Opportunities and leads FAQ (opens in a new tab)Accessed
- Angi Help Center: How to request a lead credit (opens in a new tab)Accessed
- Angi Help Center: How to cancel your Angi agreement (opens in a new tab)Accessed
- FTC: Order requires HomeAdvisor to pay $7.2 million (January 2023) (opens in a new tab)Accessed
- Networx: Reviews and leads (opens in a new tab)Accessed
- Networx: Contractor leads (opens in a new tab)Accessed
- Google Local Services Ads Help: About Local Services Ads (opens in a new tab)Accessed
- Google Local Services Ads Help: How leads work (opens in a new tab)Accessed
- Yelp for Business: Using Request a Quote (opens in a new tab)Accessed
- Yelp for Business: Things to know about advertising on Yelp (opens in a new tab)Accessed
- Yelp Support: Cost-per-click advertising (opens in a new tab)Accessed
- Houzz Pro: Pricing (opens in a new tab)Accessed
- Houzz Pro: Lead generation (opens in a new tab)Accessed
- Bark Help: How many professionals can respond (opens in a new tab)Accessed
- Bark Help: Credits and pricing (opens in a new tab)Accessed
- Bark Help: Returning a lead (opens in a new tab)Accessed
- Bark Help: Why a return is declined (opens in a new tab)Accessed
- Porch: For pros (opens in a new tab)Accessed
- HomeGuide: For pros (opens in a new tab)Accessed
- HomeGuide: Terms of service (opens in a new tab)Accessed
- eLocal: Plumbing leads (opens in a new tab)Accessed
- Service Direct: Home page (opens in a new tab)Accessed
- Service Direct Support: Billable and non-billable leads (opens in a new tab)Accessed
- Jobber Community: Is Angi worth it for home service business owners (opens in a new tab)Accessed
Next steps
Where to go from here
Your trade
How the Partner Program works for your trade: the jobs, the licensing check and how commission is paid.
See your tradeRun your numbers
A free calculator to check the margin on a job before you price it.
Open the calculatorLead platforms
What each lead source charges, what it includes and the alternatives, from published terms.
All lead platform guidesHow the Partner Program works
We build and run a local brand for your trade in your area. The calls ring on your phone and you pay commission only on jobs you close.
See the Partner ProgramApply to the Partner Program
Calls from your own area under a local brand. Commission only on closed jobs.
Apply
Last reviewed: