Skip to content
Two builders reading a set of plans together inside a timber house under construction

Lead platforms

Exclusive contractor leads (2026): who gets the same lead, and what it costs per job

By· Founder, Made For BuildersReviewed

Exclusive vs shared: how many contractors get the same lead

It depends on the source, and only some say so in writing. Marketplaces share each request with up to four or five pros. Pay-per-call sellers and Google Local Services Ads put one customer through to one business. Several sources sell exclusivity without a number. Below is each rule in the source's own words.

How many contractors can get the same customer, in each source's own words (checked 17 November 2026)
SourceShared or exclusiveWhat the source saysMissed calls
Angi (HomeAdvisor)Shared, up to 5"Each time a homeowner submits a project request, we will match them with no more than five pros." (Angi)Charged "whether or not you open or respond"
ThumbtackShared, 5 in the first 4 hours, then more"we limit the number of pros a customer can contact to five in the first four hours of their search." (Thumbtack)Refund if the customer replies to no pro in 72 hours
NetworxShared, up to 4"We match these motivated buyers with a maximum of four appropriate professionals in their area." (Networx)Not stated
BarkShared, up to 5"5 professionals can respond to any one customer" (Bark)Not applicable: you choose leads
Yelp Request a QuoteShared, number not publishedRequests "get sent to multiple businesses on Yelp that can meet their needs." (Yelp)Not applicable
HomeGuideLimited, number not published"We limit the competition so you win more jobs." (HomeGuide)Not stated
FixrBoth"You pay per lead (shared or exclusive)." (Fixr)Not stated
eLocalExclusive calls"You get exclusive access to live phone calls — no competing with a list of other contractors for the same customer." (eLocal)"A call is deemed billable if it rang for 10 or more seconds"
Service DirectExclusive callsHelps companies "get exclusive calls that turn into customers." (Service Direct)"Unanswered calls are always Billable."
InquirlyExclusive"Every single lead we send is exclusive to your company." (Inquirly)Billable if "answered by voicemail or rings more than 4 times"
Google Local Services AdsDirect to your businessYou "receive leads directly from potential customers." (Google)Charged if the caller stays on the line more than 20 seconds
Partner ProgramOne partner per trade per areaCalls for your trade in your ZIP codes go only to you while you meet the agreementNothing to pay on calls that don't become jobs
Quotes are copied from each source's own page; links open the page we captured. Prices per lead are on contractor leads, Angi leads cost and Networx cost for contractors. We do not rate sources.

HomeAdvisor and Angi. The FTC described "HomeAdvisor, which also does business as Angi Leads and HomeAdvisor Powered by Angi" (FTC, January 2023), so the Angi row is the one to read for HomeAdvisor leads. Angi adds that the number of pros "depends on the type of lead and their service location".

Thumbtack after four hours. Its terms add: "After four hours, customers can contact additional pros" (Thumbtack). Opportunities, the jobs you reach out to yourself, close when "Five pros have already expressed interest in the job" (Thumbtack). Full terms: Thumbtack for pros.

Bark shows the count before you buy: "You can see how many professionals have already responded before you decide to purchase" (Bark). Google Local Services Ads is not called exclusive by Google, but the customer contacts one business through its ad; for message leads, Google prices partly on "Whether the customer has contacted other Local Services advertisers" (Google).

Three kinds of "exclusive", and what to ask before you pay

Exclusive can mean three different things: one buyer per lead (pay-per-call and exclusive-lead sellers), a customer who contacted your business directly (Local Services Ads, your own profile and ads), or one company per trade per area. They differ in who owns the customer relationship and in what you pay for a missed call.

  • One buyer per lead

    A seller generates the request or call and sells it once. eLocal, Service Direct and Inquirly describe their calls or leads this way. You still pay per call, and their own billing rules charge for unanswered calls.

  • A direct contact

    The customer picks your business and calls or messages it, through Local Services Ads, your Google Business Profile or your own ads. No one else receives that call, but a missed one can still be billed or lost.

  • One company per area

    Exclusivity by territory: a brand, listing or program that sends a trade's calls in a ZIP code to one company. The Partner Program works this way and charges nothing per call.

Questions to ask any seller of exclusive leads. Get the answers in writing, in the contract or the help center:

  • How many companies receive the same customer, and for how long? Does the limit reset after a set time, as Thumbtack's does after four hours?
  • Is it a form or a live call? If a call, what minimum duration makes it billable, and is an unanswered call billable?
  • Which leads can be credited, within how many days, and is "the customer hired someone else" a valid reason?
  • Is there a minimum term, a monthly commitment or a prepaid balance that renews automatically?
  • Whose brand and phone number does the customer see? If you stop paying, does the customer still have your number?
  • Do you set the price per lead, or does the seller change it with demand?

Exclusive vs shared: the cost per closed job math

An exclusive lead costs less per job only if it closes more often by a bigger factor than its price is higher. If an exclusive call costs 2.25 times a shared lead, it has to close at least 2.25 times as often. Missed calls you are billed for count against the exclusive side.

The formula. Cost per closed job = price per lead ÷ share of leads that close. So an exclusive lead at price E beats a shared lead at price S only when E ÷ S is smaller than (exclusive close rate ÷ shared close rate). Neither the marketplaces nor the call sellers publish average close rates, so use your own.

Why shared leads close less often. With a request shared five ways, if every company were equally fast and equally priced, each would win about 1 in 5 of the homeowners who hire anyone. In practice it is not equal: Angi says "The majority of closed leads are won by the first pro to contact the homeowner" and that calling within 15 minutes "more than doubles your chances of connecting" (Angi). These are Angi's statements, not figures we have checked.

Example only: round numbers to show the break-even, not prices, averages or forecasts
Shared leadExclusive call, closes 1 in 3Exclusive call, closes 1 in 4
Price (example)$40$90$90
Leads or calls bought201010
Spend$800$900$900
Jobs closed2.5 (1 in 8)3.3 (1 in 3)2.5 (1 in 4)
Cost per closed job$320$270$360
Break-even here: $90 ÷ $40 = 2.25, so the exclusive call must close at least 2.25 times as often as the shared lead. If 2 in 10 calls are missed and still billed, the 1-in-3 column falls to about 1 in 3.75 and the gap closes.

Missed calls on exclusive sources. Pay-per-call sellers bill the call, not the conversation: Service Direct says "Unanswered calls are always Billable", with a minimum billable length "currently 20 seconds" (Service Direct); eLocal bills a call that "rang for 10 or more seconds" (eLocal); Inquirly bills a call that is "answered by voicemail or rings more than 4 times" (Inquirly). Google charges when "You missed a phone call during your business hours and the customer stays on the line for more than 20 seconds" (Google).

Commission instead of a price per lead. In the Partner Program you pay nothing per call, and on a closed job 20% of the labor on service and repair, or 15% of the net on installations and replacements (how commission works). On a repair with $400 of labor that is $80; on an $8,000 installation, $1,200. Calls that don't close cost nothing. Put your own numbers in the calculator below, then check what the job leaves you with the job profit margin calculator.

Exclusive or shared: your cost per closed job

Run it twice: once with your shared-lead price and close rate, once with the exclusive price and close rate. Example numbers to start; change them to yours.

Run your numbers

Paying per lead vs paying per job

Paying per lead versus paying a commission only when a job closes. Put in what you pay today and see both models side by side.

Example numbers. Change them to yours.

Most of your work is

Labor plus any markup you add to parts. Parts at cost carry no commission.

Buying leads today

$200

per closed job

$1,000 a month for 5 closed jobs

Partner Program

$70

commission per closed job (20 % of labor)

$350 a month if the same 5 jobs came from brand calls

The difference

Difference per job
$130
Difference a month
$650

On these numbers, the commission would be $130 less per closed job than buying leads: $650 a month.

Apply to the Partner Program

Hypothetical example using your numbers, for illustration only. Not a prediction or guarantee of calls, jobs or earnings: we don't guarantee any number of calls. Your results depend on your area, demand, prices and work.

Exclusive HVAC leads and exclusive plumbing leads

The same rules apply by trade: marketplaces share HVAC and plumbing requests under their usual limits, and call sellers sell trade-specific exclusive calls. Emergency work (no heat, no cooling, a burst pipe) is phone-first, so for these trades the exclusive product is usually a call, and missed-call billing matters more.

  • HVAC. Fixr sells HVAC leads both ways and describes the exclusive version as "no racing other contractors to call first" (Fixr). Google ranks Local Services Ads partly on responsiveness and warns that "Missed calls may negatively affect your responsiveness" (Google). Prices and sources for the trade: HVAC leads.
  • Plumbing. eLocal's plumbing page sells "exclusive access to live phone calls" and lets you request a credit "on any call within 4-days of receiving it" (eLocal). Inquirly offers refunds "within 7 days of the date they are received" (Inquirly). Prices and sources: plumbing leads.

What contractors report about shared and exclusive leads

Below are posts by contractors on public forums, quoted word for word and linked. They are individual experiences, not averages and not our assessment of any source. Review sites and Reddit threads we tried did not allow automated reading on 17 November 2026, so we do not quote them.

  • A wallpaper installer on the Thumbtack Community forum (February 2026): "I’ve received leads where the client sends the request to five or six pros, and in the end they never answer the phone or reply to messages." (Thumbtack Community)
  • A pro in a Thumbtack Community thread on lead prices: "I would look at cost per booked job, which services convert best, and which customers become repeat clients." (Thumbtack Community)
  • A business owner on the Jobber community forum: "Most of my business now comes from other customers, not from ads or lead services." (Jobber Community)
  • Angi, on its own credits: situations such as a homeowner who hired another pro "are accounted for in our lead pricing, so they are not eligible for credits" (Angi).
Worker in a hard hat and hi-vis vest checking a window frame in an empty, freshly painted room

If you'd rather not buy leads at all

The calls no one else receives are the ones that come to your own name and number: a Google Business Profile, reviews, referrals, your own ads. Or a local brand built for your trade and ZIP codes, where you pay commission on closed jobs instead of a price per lead.

  • Your own profile and ads. Google lists "A free Google Business Profile" (Google). Size paid search with the Google Ads ROI calculator.
  • Compare the platforms' terms side by side: apps like Thumbtack Pro.
  • A partner brand. In the Partner Program we build and run a local brand for your trade and area: name, website, tracked numbers, Google Business Profile and local SEO. One partner per trade per area. No setup fee, no monthly fee, nothing per lead: commission only on jobs you close (rates). The brand and numbers belong to us; you can leave with 30 days' notice.

Made For Builders is not a contractor and does not perform, supervise or guarantee any work. We have no US results yet and do not promise a number of calls. Launch areas: Markets.

Partners keep the calls from their own area. Commission only on closed jobs: see the rates.

Exclusive contractor leads: frequently asked questions

What are exclusive contractor leads?

Leads or calls sold to one contractor only, instead of being shared with several. Pay-per-call sellers such as eLocal, Service Direct and Inquirly describe their leads this way. Marketplaces such as Angi, Thumbtack, Networx and Bark share each request with up to four or five pros.

Are Angi and HomeAdvisor leads exclusive?

No. Angi says each request is matched with no more than five pros, and the FTC describes HomeAdvisor as doing business as Angi Leads. Details: Angi leads cost.

Are Google Local Services Ads leads exclusive?

Google does not use the word. The customer contacts your business directly through your ad, so the call itself is yours. For message leads, Google's price depends partly on whether the customer has contacted other advertisers.

Are exclusive leads "worth it" for HVAC and plumbing?

Only if they close more often by a bigger factor than their price is higher. A call at 2.25 times the price of a shared lead needs to close at least 2.25 times as often. Run your own numbers in the calculator on this page.

Do I pay for missed calls on exclusive call programs?

Often, yes. Service Direct says unanswered calls are always billable; eLocal bills calls that rang 10 seconds or more; Inquirly bills calls that go to voicemail. Google Local Services Ads charges a missed call if the caller stays on the line more than 20 seconds.

How do I get exclusive leads without paying per lead?

Calls to your own name and number (Google Business Profile, reviews, referrals) cost no fee per lead. A partner brand for your trade and area, paid only by commission on closed jobs, is another route: see the Partner Program.

Sources and method

Every quote on this page was read on the source's own page on 17 November 2026 and saved with a capture. Where a source publishes no number, we say so. Example numbers are round and labeled as examples. We do not rate platforms. Reviewed every six months.

Sources

  1. Angi Help Center: Opportunities and leads FAQ (opens in a new tab)Accessed
  2. Angi Help Center: How to request a lead credit (opens in a new tab)Accessed
  3. Angi Help Center: Why it's important to call quickly (opens in a new tab)Accessed
  4. FTC: Order requires HomeAdvisor to pay $7.2 million (January 2023) (opens in a new tab)Accessed
  5. Thumbtack Help: Quality Commitment (opens in a new tab)Accessed
  6. Thumbtack Help: Quality Commitment terms (opens in a new tab)Accessed
  7. Thumbtack Help: Opportunities (opens in a new tab)Accessed
  8. Thumbtack Community: Leads payment (opens in a new tab)Accessed
  9. Thumbtack Community: How leads are priced (opens in a new tab)Accessed
  10. Networx: Contractor leads (opens in a new tab)Accessed
  11. Bark Help: How many professionals can respond (opens in a new tab)Accessed
  12. Yelp for Business: Using Request a Quote (opens in a new tab)Accessed
  13. HomeGuide: For pros (opens in a new tab)Accessed
  14. Fixr: HVAC leads for pros (opens in a new tab)Accessed
  15. eLocal: Plumbing leads (opens in a new tab)Accessed
  16. eLocal Help: Valid and invalid calls (opens in a new tab)Accessed
  17. Service Direct: Home page (opens in a new tab)Accessed
  18. Service Direct Support: Billable and non-billable leads (opens in a new tab)Accessed
  19. Inquirly: Help center (opens in a new tab)Accessed
  20. Inquirly: Partner help center (opens in a new tab)Accessed
  21. Google Local Services Ads Help: About Local Services Ads (opens in a new tab)Accessed
  22. Google Local Services Ads Help: How leads work (opens in a new tab)Accessed
  23. Google Local Services Ads Help: Ranking (opens in a new tab)Accessed
  24. Google Ads Help: Google Business Profile (opens in a new tab)Accessed
  25. Jobber Community: The best way to get leads (opens in a new tab)Accessed

Next steps

Where to go from here

  • Your trade

    How the Partner Program works for your trade: the jobs, the licensing check and how commission is paid.

    See your trade
  • Run your numbers

    A free calculator to check the margin on a job before you price it.

    Open the calculator
  • Lead platforms

    What each lead source charges, what it includes and the alternatives, from published terms.

    All lead platform guides
  • How the Partner Program works

    We build and run a local brand for your trade in your area. The calls ring on your phone and you pay commission only on jobs you close.

    See the Partner Program
  • Apply to the Partner Program

    Calls from your own area under a local brand. Commission only on closed jobs.

    Apply

Last reviewed: